For many years here at Innocent Bystander, I armchair-quarterbacked my favorite TV series, 24. Every Monday night, after an episode, I shared my thoughts, hopes and criticisms of the show. I can't pretend for a second to be qualified to write eloquently or even seriously about Lost, at least not on the level I assumed I was capable of for the adventures of Jack Bauer, nor do I have the desire to write about it each week. But as sure as there's no 24 on in 2008, Lost has become the most fascinating drama on network TV. Again.
I did watch the first season and pretty much grew tired of it towards the end. The second season sucked me in with the hatch storyline, but just as soon kicked me out, after the "Tailies"--people who survived the crash from the other end of the plane--were introduced. And the third season meandered about until somehow the show regained its focus and came back for a rip-roaring season-ending run of about 6 shows.
Now in season four, Lost has achieved a plateau unseen in its history. Each episode so far this season has revealed something new, and while Thursday's show--focusing on Desmond Hume, the Scotsman who was on the island, living in the hatch before the plane crashed--was the weakest of the year, it was still amazing.
Lost seems to have adapted the philosophy that made Heroes such a good show in its first season. That philosophy was giving the viewing public what it wanted: A nice, big, juicy bit of information each and every episode. In this, the first of its scheduled abbreviated seasons--16 episodes scheduled to run for 16 straight weeks over the next 3 years--Lost is doing that and throwing onto the pile a shovelful of great writing. Of course, into that 16-week schedule stumbled the Writers Strike, and we'll be left with a 13-episode season.
If you're not watching the current season, or are trying to get caught up with the show by watching the DVDs of seasons 1, 2, and/or 3, STOP READING NOW. Spoilers lurk ahead, even if I am a bit late to the writing about Lost party.
The last episode of last season revealed a new twist: the flash-forward. Lost has always relied on a two-tiered storyline. Each episode revolved around a particular cast member, and we were given a glimpse of their life pre-crash. Now we've learned that there's a group of people known as "the Oceanic 6," who got off the island. So far, we know four of them are Jack and Kate (both of whom were revealed at the end of last season), Hurley, and Sayid. Last week's episode revealed Baby Aaron is also one of them. That leaves one more. Is it evil Ben, also glimpsed in an episode this season? Granted, Ben has always had the ability to get off the island, one way or another, so I'm guessing he isn't part of the Oceanic 6. And obviously, as of Thursday night, Desmond is also off the island, but he can't be one of them since he was on the island before the crash. Also still MIA--but in the credits each week of season 4--is Michael (Harold Perrineau). One of the six, or one that got away on his own (Michael escaped in a barter with Ben at the end of the second season)? And while I'm not the one in my little circle of Lost devotees who came up with this theory, I think it's pretty obvious who Ben's spy on the boat is: Michael. This was underscored by the infirmary door suddenly being opened so Desmond, Sayid and Minkowski could get to the radio room.
In an article in last week's Entertainment Weekly, producers/writers Damon Lindeloff and Carleton Cuse revealed we'd know the identity of all six of the "6" by the time the show takes a break on March 13 (five additional episodes will air by the end of the traditional network TV season in May; Lost had eight episodes in the can when they debuted during the Writer's Strike). But everything we've seen so far only brings up more questions. And Lost is a show famous for bringing up questions...
To wit: How did Baby Aaron end up with Kate? The erstwhile criminal didn't even want to touch the kid as a baby on the island. And how much time has passed since they left the island? Baby Aaron is more like toddler Aaron now, looking to be in the 3 or so year range. And the presence of the baby certainly explains Kate's cryptic comment to Jack in the season 3 ender about getting back before he asks about her (or some such words..I forget the exact verbiage, which proves I'm an unfit Lost-blogger).
Are the other survivors still on the island or dead? Did Kate gain custody of Claire's baby because she's dead? Did she die by trying to leave the island, with that whole baby/mother thing that's been hanging around as a subplot since the beginning of the show? Was there some kind of wholesale massacre of the survivors, or did they opt to stay behind? Did only six make it out due to the island's wonky premise, that it seems to exist in some kind of other dimension, where time either stands still or moves faster? (Honestly...I can't figure out the physics on this, but then again, I have to think two or three times to figure out a tip these days.) Did only six get out because the "window of opportunity" to get everyone out crashed and burned at some point?
Other questions abound: Why does Jack so desperately want to get back to the island? Why is Sayid working as a hired assassin for Ben? Does Kate not want her mother to meet her grandson, because she knows she'll instantly know the baby isn't Kate's? Does all of this sound like some kind of soap opera on steroids? That's exactly what it is and more.
One thing is certain: Lost got bogged down in the past by the very thing that's making it great this year: the introduction of new characters. I'm not quite sure what the difference is, because the tanker folk seem to be equal to or greater in number than the Tailies and the Others. I think part of the difference is while introducing all these new characters, the producers are turning back to the original cast members--those that are left--who are the most popular, Jack, Kate, Sayid, and Hurley, and telling us new stories--involving flash-forwards on each of them. The episode on Sayid, co-written by comics writer Brian K. Vaughan, was one of the best episodes of the show, period. And the interesting thing about the show is how the dual nature of the storyline--island scenes with flash forwards (although last night's episode about Desmond played with time altogether)--has changed. Now the island scenes are in the past, the flash-forwards are in present time. At least, I think they are.
So, yeah. I'm lost in Lost this season, but unlike previous years, it's the good kind of lost. Totally immersed, almost drowning in it, occasionally coming up for air, but welcoming every time it pulls me back in, draws me back under, and makes me reel from it all.